Sin of Existence

Image by Sasin Tipchai from Pixabay 

Bringing life into existence is a miraculous thing and women are the divine force that makes this magic happen, while many consider birth as luck but it really is an accident, there is no merit or qualification required to be born in a privileged or oppressed caste family. It is just a game of probability that determines your birth. People claiming credit for their ancestor’s doings innately lack self-identity whilst they don’t have much to contribute to the community/society, they lack any achievements of their own. Since they don’t have much to offer they hide behind their (so-called) shield of Royal legitimacy. They try to claim superiority over others to mask their impotency.

On the other hand, being born in an oppressed class family is a nightmare waiting to unfold for many individuals. The only sin they ever committed was being born in an oppressed class by accident. As a popular Indian saying goes “Your birth is determined by your Karma (Deeds)”, it is because of my past life’s sin or virtue my present life is determined. There are many paradoxical analogies in Indian scriptures, “your varna (social-class) is determined by your occupation” whilst contradictorily also maintaining “your varna is determined by your birth”.

How does a foetus know that they have sinned in their past life and they will be ostracized and prejudiced in this birth, once you are born you are not a blessing but a burden and an existential omen according to the much-privileged class population. Moving on to the name-giving ceremony (about a century ago), you can’t take honorific titles or names of the elite class that are reserved for privileged class men/women. Your name will be a resemblance of your poverty, your occupation or any degrading animal names.

The mortality rate of shudra/dalit women due to childbirth is higher than that of elite class women. They are not allowed to proper means of a health system that the privileged class enjoy. In certain rural areas hospitals won’t tend to people from oppressed class. Once the baby is born it may or may not get proper nutrition since the mother is not allowed to consume staple crops other than wild millets and oats.

If a dalit/shudra kid wanders into a privileged class neighbourhood they will be driven away by sticks and stones. If they are seen playing with the privileged class they will be beaten and their family members will be assaulted. If you dare pick a fight with a privileged class kid then your mother and siblings will be stripped and will be paraded through the town to remind you of your place in society.

Even today education is a distant dream to many shudra/dalit children. If a kid overcomes all the societal hurdles and goes to school they are subjected to humiliation. They are made to sit separately from the privileged class students mostly at the back of the class or behind a barrier separating the privileged class and oppressed class, certain institutions make them sit on the ground while reserving the benches for the elite, while certain institutions make them sit outside the classroom. Teachers will refrain from teaching or clarifying any of their doubts. They will be constantly reminded of their oppressed births while singing songs of their superiority. They will be involuntarily made to clean toilets and classrooms, if anyone asks “why we have to clean the toilets?” they will be replied “It is your karma!!! / It is your ancestral occupation!!! / You have been destined to do this and you are not fit to receive education!!!”

The oppressed class should take education as a weapon, they need to be present in diverse fields instead of restricting themselves to their community. It should be a moral duty of every oppressed class individual to uplift at least one member from their community.

Standard

SAVARNA FEMINISM

To give a clear picture “Savarna (elite) Feminism” is equivalent to the “White Feminism”; which caters to privileged, elite and upper-caste women while they will leave their not so lucky socio-economically oppressed sisters hanging. They will call out to you only when they or (women from) their community face any adversity. It is like “to me you are a Neech-jati (low-borne) and I consider myself superior to you but if I face any problem, you too will have to fight in name of my dharma (faith)”.

Savarna feminists are deaf to the atrocities of Savarna men, but they will lash out vehemently at issues caused by oppressed/minorities. Most of the time they will purposely fail to address the elephant in the room. They are okay with things until and unless it doesn’t directly affect them, these are the same kind who will have 3 square meals and will ask you to donate your food.

The problems of oppressed class women and savarna women are astronomically different. When “Savarna feminist” expresses her inconvenience it ends with her, but when an oppressed caste woman communicates her ailment it is the cumulative anguish of her predecessors when she speaks she doesn’t just speak for herself but all womankind irrespective of social hierarchy. When Savarna feminists were milking the juice out of the #MeToo movement, oppressed classes were fighting for better working conditions, protesting against caste discrimination, demanding rights to education, rights to gender equality.

If there is one thing that is much more frightening than their (savarna) roar is their silence. Their bravery was elevating when they shook up the Indian sub-continent for the Nirbhaya movement but where were they when the Khairlanji happened, where were the proud Indian lionesses when Hathras happened. The truth is when it comes down to privilege or companionship, they won’t hesitate to ditch you to maintain their social class in society. Similar to certain inept politicians who unashamedly ask for votes when election season is just around the corner, Savarna feminists will not hesitate to seek your allyship under the pretence of “common good for all women”.

Dalit women are subjected to rape, sexual harassments, murders, physical violence, and attack on family members almost on a daily basis. When such cases are reported less than 30% of them gets filed, at times the victims get threatened against giving a police report; whereas about 70% of cases are filed if injustice happens to upper-caste women.

Things that upper caste women consider as basic necessity has increasingly become a privilege for oppressed class women. In 1989 when Tamil Nadu passed the bill stating women had equal rights in family properties the upper-caste women were the ones to benefit most from it but the irony is most Savarna women protested against having such privileges. Privileged women have always been detrimental to the development of oppressed class women, she is a product of her elite patriarchal society

Great social reformers such as Savitribai Phule and Fatima Sheikh after a lot of humiliation overcame disparity and because of them we are able to educate girl-child and can talk about equality, even so, we don’t celebrate teacher’s day in their remembrance. Most Savarnas won’t acknowledge the deeds of oppressed classes but rather will celebrate someone from their own class.

Savarna women think she can end casteism by boldly displaying her caste identity as a surname, she thinks she can break patriarchy by falling at the feet of her religious gurus, she thinks she can end inequality with her holy scriptures. Whatever progressiveness she talks about is centred on her privileges, she will not throw it all away for the collective good, she will only think about what’s best for her while mindful of her community’s wrath.

Women from the oppressed class were always been exploited by men. She has to go through caste discrimination, Social discrimination, discrimination at work, discrimination at educational centres etc. etc. Getting a good night’s sleep is like a distant dream to most oppressed class women when every day is a fight for survival, she doesn’t think about her hobbies or if even she had any she has to sacrifice everything to make her dreams realized.

Being a woman is tough but being an oppressed class woman is a struggle, there is nothing wrong in lending support but don’t fail to analyse whom you are supporting, what is their agenda and what are you going to gain from it because chameleons aren’t the only ones which can change colours.

Standard

Privilege of Caste

A lot of you might have heard about the privilege of birth/race/status!!! but what is the privilege of caste??? it is not like you have been born in a rich household so you have the privilege of wealth or been born in an authoritative family so you automatically have the privilege of power.

The privilege of caste is being born in the so-called priestly/warrior community and claiming other communities to be below them and oppressing them for aeons.

Can you switch your community or change your caste ???

Not exactly, if your parents belong to a specific caste that will be your destiny!!! you can be thankful to them for giving you birth in priestly or warrior class or spite them for giving you birth in peasant/labourer class.

Why is my caste lower than yours ???

It is because you have sinned in your past life and to repay the debts you will be considered as a lowly creature in this birth and you will serve the so-called elite communities, you will have to serve us and pick after us. Your very existence is to fulfil our needs.

How is one’s caste decided ???

According to Manusmriti (holy scripture), Karma (occupation) defined one’s Varna (social-order) and the type of occupation defines one’s Jatis/Jaadhi/Jaath (communities).

eg: Priestly class (priests, academicians, physicians etc), Warrior class (Kings, knights, administrators etc), Trader class (Merchants, Landowners, businessmen etc), Labour class ( pastoralist, service providers, entertainers etc)

Initially, the caste system was superfluous but realizing the advantages it held, the caste system became more and more rigid in favour of privileged castes and helped them exploit other communities.

What exactly is caste ???

For a society to function it needs each and everyone to contribute to the society, so people were segregated based on their occupation; which is the priests, academicians, warriors, traders, pastoralist, labourers and service providers. Also, the hierarchy is Priestly class > Warrior Class > Trader class > Labourers.

So in ancient times caste system was an integral part of the subcontinent and it helped the privileged castes to feed off the blood, sweat and tears of the oppressed caste.

Occupation and caste:

Occupations such as priesthood, academia and medicine are only reserved to the priestly class whereas members from other castes are not permitted to learn these skills or read the holy scriptures.

If a member from an oppressed caste is seen doing these occupations, then he or she will be punished and most of the time it is death.

In the colonial and post-colonial era, education was seen as a privilege fit only for the elite (mainly priestly class) and other classes were forbidden from gaining any form of education.

But time and again members from the oppressed class have outshone and proven them wrong, by excelling not only in academics but also in all forms of art.

Efforts are being made to uplift the denied class, but still, most oppressed classes remain in poverty and face criticism for gaining their rights.

“Education is the only way for the oppressed class to uplift themselves”

How come your caste is superior to mine ???

It is because Manusmriti (holy scripture) says so, which is written by my great forefather (belonging to the priestly class) to secure his position in society.

What if I don’t want to associate myself with your caste system ???

Then we will brand you as Avarna ( not belonging to any 4 class) and you will be considered as Ati-Shudra/Dalit (oppressed caste), your very presence is impure; wherever you go, whatever you do, however you live, you will be considered as a disgrace to this society. Not only you but your progeny and their progeny and their progeny……. will be considered as impure.

Which class do Foreigners belong to???

Technically all foreigners are Mleccha’s (Barbarians), i.e those people who do not follow a Vedic lifestyle and don’t speak Sanskrit or its affiliated tongue and lower than any other classes in the subcontinent i.e,“ Ati-ati-shudra” (lower than ati-shudra).

But there is a shift in ideology after the colonial era, wherein the European race is held supreme and the so-called privileged elite class claim their ancestry to be of the European race.

So in a way, even when classifying foreigners people of European descent are put on a pedestal and other foreign races lie below them.

What about marriage???

Inter caste marriages are frowned upon and seen as an act of impurity and pollution.

One should not marry out of their caste if by chance inter-caste marriage takes place then the man depending on the social order should marry a woman of social order equal to or lower than him.

eg: a man from a priestly class can marry a woman from priestly, warrior, trader, labourer class; but a man from warrior class can only marry a woman equal to his class or below the social order but he cannot marry a woman from the priestly class, the same way a trader can’t marry a woman above him on social order but can marry a woman equal to him or from a lower caste.

What if an upper-caste woman marries a lower caste man???

First of all, we will not let that happen and to save our honour, we will brutally eliminate her and her husband.

Even if it happens, we will shun her and her progeny as “out-castes”.

Chandala is an oppressed caste in India believed to be born from a priestly class woman and a Dalit father.

Why do I support caste-system???

I get to reap the fruits of the oppressed wherein I can exploit them more and more and make sure that my progeny can do the same thing with their successors. By keeping them below me I get a sense of power and pride.

In the modern era, although I can’t openly discriminate against them, I can wear my caste as a title to show how superior I am to them and remind them of their inferior birth.

In a public setting, my caste surname helps me get jobs, certain benefits in workspaces, easily finding friends etc etc. whereas my counterpart from oppressed caste gets none of the privileges and it becomes easy for me to brand them “you are not fit for the part !!!”

How can this social imbalance be calibrated???

Reservation

Standard